Friday, 4 January 2013

Tesco, Sainsbury and Morrison update.

Next week is a big week for the three big food retailers in the FTSE100.  All three of Tesco, Sainsbury and Morrison are due to report updates, telling us how things went over the Christmas period. All three have a lot to gain and potentially lose depending on what they report.

It has been approximately a year since Tesco reported its UK profit warning that resulted in a share slump of around 20% in a day.  Having almost touched a price of 300p over the summer, the share price has been in recovery mode on the back of a huge investment in its UK operations and its recent announcement that it is to look again at the loss making US operation Fresh and Easy. It is expected that Tesco will either scale this down massively, take on a US partner or more likely sell up completely. The market is probably looking for a further announcement on this when the company reports on 10th January. As the share price has been going up recently the good news may already be in the price, but don't be surprised if there is a further up-rating should it be announced that they are pulling out of the US. If that is also accompanied by an improvement in its UK results, then market sentiment of the good variety may suddenly be with Tesco.

Sainsbury and Morrison's are fighting different battles. Sainsbury have been performing well of late taking market share from others. It has been questioned whether they can keep this up. Morrison's on the other hand has been in the city doghouse of late, losing market share, its lack of web presence and convenience stores suddenly being seen by the market as a big negative. 
"It appears the established 2012 podium lineup (Waitrose and the discounters Aldi and Lidl) stretched their lead, but the biggest slowdown may have come at Sainsbury," said Oriel analyst Jonathan Pritchard, helping send shares in the UK's third largest grocer down 9.1p to 336p, a fall of more than 2%.

A note entitled A Tough Christmas from Morrisons house broker Jeffries also knocked confidence in the Bradford-based grocer, which finished down 2% at 257.4p. James Grzinic, of Jeffries, predicted Morrisons boss Dalton Philips would reveal a 2.8% drop in like-for-like sales for the six weeks to 30 December on Monday. Morrisons, which does not yet have a grocery website, is being left behind as the rock bottom prices offered by the discounters steal its traditional no frills formula.

"We expect Morrisons to kick off the January trading season in a weak manner," said Grzinic. "We expect hard discounters to have experienced a disproportionate improvement in market share over Christmas, particularly in the north of England. Secondly, more affluent consumers' migration to online shopping seems to have accelerated over the festive season."
http://www.equities.com/news/headline-story?dt=2013-01-03&val=887334&cat=goods

So, If Sainsbury and Morrison disappoint next week there could easily be more share price weakness. Sainsbury have had a good run on the back of improving results up to Christmas, it might be their turn to lose some of those gains if results are worse than expected.

Morrison is the difficult one to judge.  The market isn't really expecting much and results are expected to be relatively weak. If they do better than expected the shares could bounce from here, but a really bad announcement could easily see the company being given a dose of the Tesco treatment, perhaps not 20%, but 5-10% fall could easily happen with the company currently out of favour with the city. Given the company's own broker appears to be preparing the markets for disappointment, the news is unlikely to be good.

On the plus side, all three pay good dividends and that isn't likely to change next week. In fact, share price weakness could ultimately present a buying opportunity to dividend seekers as a weak price means you can buy more shares and get a bigger slice of the dividend. This kind of strategy is ok provided you are confident that any fundamental weakness in the company is likely to be a blip in the growth story rather than a sign of decline. All three of Tesco, Sainsbury and Morrison still have a lot going for them regardless of whatever they announce next week.

6 comments:

  1. You might want to check this technical analysis program:
    http://www.cognitum-research.com/en/wave-explorer

    ReplyDelete
  2. Morrison reports figures that are poor, but not as bad as expected it would seem.

    In the six weeks to 30th December total sales (excluding fuel) were down by 0.9% down 0.5% when fuel was included.

    Like-for-like sales dropped by 2.5% (or 2.2% including fuel).

    http://www.digitallook.com/cgi-bin/dlmedia/security.cgi?csi=10248&action=news&story_id=20604492

    Considering its own broker was looking at a 2.8% decline in L for L sales that's not so bad. I suppose it's possible the broker overstated the possible decline in a worst case scenario fashion. Morrison now expects to deliver full figures for the year broadly in line with expectations. Be interesting to see if their recovery plan convinces the market.

    ReplyDelete
  3. A little more on Morrison's.

    At the moment the company is involved in a share buyback that seems to have broad support. It already pays a decent dividend which in theory a share buyback helps, Vodafone are doing the same right now. Morrison is in the process of buying back around £1 billion of its shares.

    However, you do wonder whether the money could be better spent elsewhere like on beefing up its lack of an online presence. At the moment they only sell wine and some baby products online. Given the continuing growth of online sales their neglect of this is a stunning oversight which for years even the city turned a blind eye to, until that is the bottom line started to suffer. This tells you as much about the city and their "expert" analysts as it does about the business.

    A little like Tesco with its decision over Fresh and Easy in the US that gave the city something that it wanted to hear, a Morrison announcement that it plans to go online in a big way will probably see sentiment change and the share price reverse its decline. Until then the company may find the going tough against competition that is already way ahead of it. Tesco, Sainsbury and ASDA, Morrison's main big name competitors all have well advanced online shopping options, so it makes you wonder how such a major company can make such a mistake in thinking it doesn't need to do the same.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sainsbury enjoyed record-breaking Christmas trading as it increased its market share in the last three months of 2012.

    But the firm warned the celebrations would probably not last into the new year.

    "We expect the challenging economic backdrop to persist, with customers looking to re-balance their household budget after the festivities and so spending cautiously in the first few months of 2013," said Chief Executive Justin King.

    Like-for-like sales excluding fuel were up 0.9% in the 14 weeks to January 5th, while total sales were up 3.3% (excluding fuel).

    http://www.digitallook.com/cgi-bin/dlmedia/security.cgi?csi=10079&action=news&story_id=20610377

    ReplyDelete
  5. Tesco are up next, reporting tomorrow, let's see if they live up to these expectations.

    ...according to Kantar Worldpanel, Tesco raised its core grocery sales ahead of Sainsbury, Asda and Morrison in the lead up to Christmas.

    The market researcher said Tesco’s cash sales grew 4.2% in the four weeks to December 23rd, confirming the group led the UK majors for the second period running.

    The grocer saw a 6.7 % jump in food and drink sales.

    Asda’s sales grew 3.7 % while Sainsbury rose 3.3% and Morrison fell 0.6%.

    http://www.digitallook.com/cgi-bin/dlmedia/security.cgi?csi=50058&action=news&story_id=20612353

    ReplyDelete
  6. Tesco update. They seem to be the Christmas winners, at least in terms of market reaction going forward. Morrison probably can only look with envy at those increasing online sales.

    Group sales in the six weeks to January 5th increased by 3.8% including petrol while the international business performed at a similar level to the third quarter.

    In the UK, like-for-like sales edged up by 1.8%, propelled by stronger food performance than experienced in the previous year and a further improvement from the third quarter.

    Increasing online performance drove part of the rise in overall sales, with Tesco Direct purchases up by more than 16%.

    Internet-purchased food sales increased by 18% over the five week Christmas and New Year period. This was underpinned by more than 500,000 food orders being fulfilled in the week before Christmas, with almost 5% of online goods picked up by customers using Tesco’s drive-through “Click & Collect” service.

    http://www.digitallook.com/cgi-bin/dlmedia/security.cgi?csi=10091&action=news&story_id=20613331

    ReplyDelete